Nailing the Perfect Smoky Eye Was Never Easier Advertisements Step 6: Make your eyes pop Source: ulta.com Benefit Cosmetics BADgal Eyeliner Waterproof, ulta.com$20.00 For some added drama, use a black eyeliner on both your top and bottom lash line, making sure you can’t see any of the skin. This will create a sultry effect and add even more drama to your eyes. Page 4 of 6